Thursday, 29-January-2015 17:20
 
comments in
"Articles"
A message to woman engaging in political battlefields
I can't Agree more
Relations Between Regime and Opposition
thank you for this site GUYS.We need it sincerely
Democracy could not jump
Thanks dearfor your intellectual aspects about DEMOCRACY.you are always great EBTIHAG
Articles
Wednesday, 26-December-2007
Almotamar Net - BERLIN – The recent comprehensive assessment by America’s spy agencies about Iran’s nuclear program and ambitions – the so-called “National Intelligence Estimate” – has opened the door to fresh strategic discussions among the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council and Germany. Such a strategic reconsideration is probably most necessary for those in the Bush administration (and a few elsewhere), who until recently have been prophets of imminent danger. Project Syndicate - BERLIN – The recent comprehensive assessment by America’s spy agencies about Iran’s nuclear program and ambitions – the so-called “National Intelligence Estimate” – has opened the door to fresh strategic discussions among the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council and Germany. Such a strategic reconsideration is probably most necessary for those in the Bush administration (and a few elsewhere), who until recently have been prophets of imminent danger.

For Europeans, the NIE has not removed, but rather confirmed, the concerns that in 2003 prompted the EU-3 (Britain, France, and Germany) – namely, that Iran’s nuclear program could eventually give it a military nuclear capability, and that even before that point, it might trigger regional nuclear proliferation.

The NIE also confirmed two assumptions that have since guided European diplomatic approach: Iran reacts to external incentives and disincentives, and taking legitimate Iranian interests into consideration is the best way to influence Iran’s leaders. Most Europeans who have been dealing with the issue also assume that Iran is aiming at capacities that would eventually make available all options, including quick development of a nuclear weapon, rather than actually acquiring, let alone testing, a weapon and thereby violating the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

So concern about Iran’s nuclear program is still justified. The robust diplomatic approach that is needed to confront the problem must include three components. First, it should be based on a broad international consensus. Second, it should clearly communicate that the issue is proliferation, not the nature of the Iranian regime. Third, any further sanctions should be accompanied by an earnest offer of dialogue and engagement.

By contrast, some American policymakers continue to believe that Iran would abandon its enrichment program if only the European Union imposed unilateral sanctions. But a clear-headed analysis of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s behavior indicates that EU sanctions would lead to more trade diversion, with China, Russia, Turkey, or Dubai benefiting from reduced levels of European exports to Iran.

Of course, some imports would become more expensive for Iran, but the economic effect of such sanctions would remain limited. Politically, Ahmadinejad certainly would not miss the chance to exploit unilateral measures for propaganda purposes – claiming that Iran has a conflict not with the international community, but with imperialist states intent on depriving his country of technological progress.

For these reasons, Europeans favor a new Security Council resolution, even if its measures are weaker than what the United States or the EU could impose unilaterally. Such a resolution would send an effective signal to the Iranian public and political elite that Iran is in conflict with the entire international community.

Iranians do not like to be isolated; even the clerical elite has a strong interest in exchanges with the rest of the world, and they like to send their children to Western schools. Making it obvious that it is Ahmadinejad’s policies that are isolating Iran would strengthen the still-fragile anti-Ahmadinejad alliance of pragmatic conservatives and reformers, which has lately become more vocal.

This is important to bear in mind, as a parliamentary (majlis) election is scheduled for March 2008. The election will not be entirely free, but the government will be unable to manipulate them entirely. The majlis plays a role in the political process, to the point of being able to induce or hinder policy changes: witness the way a conservative majlis blocked reformist President Mohammad Khatami in the last years of his term.

Europeans should now be confident enough to call for a common policy with the US that focuses on domestic developments in Iran. Such a policy can include additional Security Council sanctions, but it must also carry an offer of dialogue that pragmatic forces in Iran would not refuse.

Both the EU and the US should be prepared to enter into direct, comprehensive, and unconditional negotiations with Iran. Where security guarantees are concerned, America is Iran’s actual foe and potential partner. So far, the two governments have communicated either through the EU or on strictly limited issues through their ambassadors in Baghdad. The US has so far insisted that it will agree to a comprehensive dialogue only if Iran first suspends its enrichment activities. But this should be the result of, not a precondition for, negotiations.

Whatever the US and Europe decide to do about Iran will affect that country’s internal political dynamics. There are no easy mechanics at work here. The best method of strengthening Ahmadinejad, however, appears to be to threaten the country and the regime as a whole. An honest offer of engagement would allow Ahmadinejad’s pragmatic opponents to show that it is Iran’s president and his controversial policies, not the West, that are at fault.

Volker Perthes is Chairman and Director of Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, Berlin.

Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2007.
www.project-syndicate.org

More from "Articles"

Other titles:
Tuesday, 27-January-2015
The Special Adviser to the UN Secretary-General on Yemen has revealed that the political powers representatives reiterated their commitment to continue their consultations to end the political crisis in Yemen.

Jamal Benomar made the statement after a meeting held on Monday with representatives of the political forces signatories to the Peace and National Partnership Agreement (PNPA).
Monday, 26-January-2015
Two terrorists were killed in a foiled attack on a military site belonging to the 115th Infantry Brigade in Khanfar district of Abyan province, a military source said Monday.

A number of the attackers were injured during repelling the attack and the rest escaped, leaving their weapons, the source added.
Sunday, 25-January-2015
The board of the House of Representatives (Parliament) has postponed the parliament's emergency meeting initially scheduled for Sunday.

The meeting was delayed until "another date to be set later," the house's board said.

It said the postponement aimed at allowing more time to "inform all members of the parliament to attend."
Saturday, 24-January-2015
The Speaker of Parliament Yahya al-Raei arrived in Riyadh Air Base on Saturday at head of Yemeni official delegation to offer condolences on the death of King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz.

King Abdullah, who had ruled since 2005 and was said to be aged about 90, died early on Friday.
Saturday, 24-January-2015

A Yemeni delegation led by Speaker of the Parliament Yahya al-Raei headed to the Saudi capital Riyadh on Saturday to offer condolences on the death of King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz.

King Abdullah, who had ruled since 2005 and was said to be aged about 90, died early on Friday after a short illness.
Wednesday, 21-January-2015
Congress (GPC) and its allies are still asking for the the outputs of the national dialogue conference that agreed upon the agreement of peace and partnership and the importance of a quick working on the implementation of the four points in the speech of Mr. AbdulMalik Badr al-Din al-Houthi yesterday. He added that the points have been agreed upon in the peace agreement and partnership that signed by all parties in order to take out of the Yemen political tension and to avoid violence and bloodshed
Tuesday, 20-January-2015
The Arab League called on Tuesday all the political parties to immediately stop and reject all forms of violence.

Deputy Secretary General of the Arab League Ahmad bin Hali said in a press statement the secretariat is following up with great interest the developments in Yemen, and carrying out calls in order to assist containing the crisis.

He also urged all parties to support efforts exerted by President Abdo Rabbu Mansour Hadi in accordance with the Peace and Partnership Agreement that based on the National Dialogue Conference (NDC)'s outputs in order to ensure Yemen's security and stability.

From another hand, the Egyptian Ministry of Foreign Affairs appealed the political components to hold their responsibilities in contributing to achieve stability and peace in the country
Tuesday, 20-January-2015
The Government has called all the political parties that signed the Peace and Partnership Agreement to hold an emergency meeting on Tuesday morning.

The meeting would be chaired by President Abdo Rabbu Mansour Hadi and attended by bodies of the Parliament and the Shura Council.
Monday, 19-January-2015
Interior Minister Jalal al-Rowaishan affirmed on Monday a ceasefire came into force between ' Ansar Allah ' and Presidential Security Brigades in Sana'a as of 4:30 p.m.

The decision was made by a Presidential Committee includes the Defense and Interior Ministers, Special Security Forces Commander and President adviser Saleh al-Sammad.
Saturday, 17-January-2015
The five detained fishermen by the Sudanese government returned home on Saturday after being seized for four months because of entering Sudan's territorial waters without prior permission.

The fishermen expressed their appreciation to the efforts of the Yemeni government and ambassador in Khartoum for releasing and returning them home.

who we are     |    Advertising     |    contact us
All rights reserved © Almotamar Net, Developed by